Overrated and Underrated Songs

[FunkyHamster]

I PASSED MY FIRST CATA!!!! :DGO ME!!! I did it on a cheapo mat, (as always ), but it was just WAY too easy. Paranoia KCET ~clean mix~ should be an 8 footer maybe even a 7 footer! I heard it used to be an 8, is that true? If it is then why the hell did they change it? It would of been fine that way.

I also think that Xenon on Standard should be a 7 instead of a 6, and that Kind Lady on Challenge should be a 7 instead of an 8. I know there are many more but I can't think of em rite now..

[psmo290]

yeah,

my opinion is that Sakura on heavy should be an 8 footer and cartoon heroes on heavy should be a 10 footers

[SSC]

I agree with the cartoon heroes. I think they should make the Healing Vision Angelic Mix to a 10 footer. I also think that they should up the difficulty on Trip Machine Climax some...

[FunkyHamster]

I haven't played Healing Vision Angelic Mix on Heavy yet, but I think it should be an 8 footer on Standard, it's the only 7 footer I haven't beaten in MAX/MAX2.

[SSC]

It's definitely tough enough...

[sly rax]

I agree on both the Paranoia KCET and Xenon comments. Xenon is a technical 6 definitely (or do I call it a technical 7, actual 6?), lacking something that would make it actually be a 7. It definitely is the second hardest Standard stage on Max2US. And yes, Paranoia KCET was an 8 originally. I get the feeling that the upgrade was honorary.

There are many songs that technically have the right rating, but are much more difficult. On ExtremeUS, we are getting the Reflex by Duran Duran, which has cata difficulty, but is an 8 step.

Personally, I think So Deep should be a ten. The only thing preventing it is that it is so repetitive that it has extremely low Chaos. That didn't stop Outer Limits from becoming a 10, though.

[lilhotboy627]

There are a lot of overrated songs yes but i dont think So Deep is one of them...its not that hard of a heavy...to me the songs that are overrated are ones like In the Navy becuz its a super-easy 8 footer...

[psmo290]

i think in the navy should be a 6 footers

[Insanemidget]

Sakura should stay a 10 footer bc it is fast and has some tough to PA parts.

Cartoon Heroes ISN'T that hard guys, it should be a 9.

Also, HVAM isn't hard at all, it's just fast streams with the occasional double step.

Trip Machine Climax is cake, definately definately not 10 foot material.

So Deep is the same thing repeated over and over again until about 2/3 of the way through, it's really not that hard either, a little stamina draining...but that's all.

I know this will come up also, Witch Doctor, not a 9 footer .

I think Mikeneko Rock and TL100S should be 9 footers.

Brilliant 2u Heavy - 7 footer
KCET + Irresistiblement + MSL = 8 footer

That's my opinion ;D

[SSC]

I agree about Sakura, but I think Cartoon Heroes is fairly tough. I always have an insanely hard time playing So Deep on heavy...

I really don't think Bag should be a 10 on Heavy... it's quite easy even without speed modifiers.

I also always struggle with Saints Go Marching In on Heavy... up it to a 10 footer I say.

One more, I think Max 300 should be a 5 maybe 4 footer on light rather a 6.

[Insanemidget]

Uhh

Maybe Bag is fairly easy to PASS, but it's hard as hell to PA. I am sure you can pass it, just with 2900579 greats.

And you guys need to stop saying, "I suck at this song, it should be a 10 then!".

Saints Go Marching? no fucking way.

[SSC]

Haha... true about the Bag thing I guess.

I guess SGMI really isn't that hard... it just has some tricky footings.

[psmo290]

took me awhile AA that song. took me about 2 weeks to do it

[SSC]

I can barely pass it...

[sly rax]

I just got MaxUS yesterday (wow, R&P is fun!) and I'm going to say that Broken My Heart really doesn't feel like a 9. It was hard near the beginning, but the difficulty kind of faded away as it went on.

HVAM definitely doesn't feel like a ten. It definitely is a hard 9, though.

Yeah, I just basically said "I can't beat So Deep, so it is 10 blah blah." Sorry.

[psmo290]

yeah, i agree, HVAM doesn't really feel like a 10 but it is a very hard 9 footer. And broken my heart is pretty easy, should be a 7 footer

[LegendofMatt]

I agree with Insane with the brilliant 2u, cause that one part in it makes no sense with any of the sounds like the other brilliant 2u's do. I think Witch Doctor and Waka Laka should be 9's. Cartoon Heroes is fine at a 9 i say. Maybe MaxX U. should be a Flashing 10, cause...that beginning jump parts...i hate those!

[Insanemidget]

The steps to B2U do make sense with the music, it's just fast 16th notes.

Broken my Heart isn't a 7...wtf. It's like a 460 combo, yea, ok.

[LegendofMatt]

The b2u steps for heavy are retarded as crap though compared to KOG.G3 and B2U Oni steps. Those atleast make sense.

[SSC]

Okay I'm sorry, I'm not a great DDR player, I'm only a 6-7 footer, but Bag on heavy is easy. I can full combo it at the arcade with speed mods. Sure I got like 150 greats, but I think it should be a 9.